Shayna, what a great idea! Why didn't I think of that (making her think we were actually going somewhere)! :-) The good thing is that I also love being out, so we would actually take my daughter on a drive.
Whenever she got cranky or was crying/fussy in the evenings, we would get ready, put her in the car seat, and take her for a drive, usually on Lake Shore Drive. She was usually asleep within 10 - 15 minutes. It was actually soothing for all of us and a nice end to the evening.